Spray-In vs Drop-In Bedliners: Which Option Offers Superior Truck Bed Protection?

Why Your Truck Bed Needs Protection

Your truck bed endures a lot — from carrying tools for work to transporting gear for adventures. Without proper protection, minor scratches can quickly lead to rust and a significant loss in value.

Two popular options for safeguarding your truck bed are spray-in bedliners and drop-in bedliners. Each has its strengths and weaknesses. At Crank’s Bedliners & Truck Accessories, we’ve installed hundreds of bedliners across Orange County. Here’s what you should know before making your choice.

What is a Drop-In Bedliner?

Drop-in bedliners are plastic liners molded to fit inside your truck bed. They are easy to install and remove, making them a common choice for many truck owners.

Pros:

• Lower upfront cost: Generally priced between $300 to $600, drop-in bedliners often come as the more budget-friendly option.

  
  

• Quick installation: The installation usually takes only a couple of hours, allowing you to get back to using your truck in no time.

  
  

• Easy to remove if needed: If you plan to sell your truck or switch liners, this option can be taken out with relative ease.

  
  

Cons:

• Can trap water and sand, leading to hidden rust: Studies show that up to 30% of drop-in liners can develop rust issues due to moisture accumulation in hidden areas.

  
  

• Tend to shift over time, scratching the paint underneath: Many users report that movement while driving can scratch the truck's surface, compromising the paint.

  
  

• Louder and less “custom fit”: These liners often move during transport, leading to noise and an imperfect fit.

  
  

Best for:

Budget-conscious owners or individuals who expect to replace their truck soon.

What is a Spray-In Bedliner?

Spray-in bedliners are unique coatings applied directly to your truck bed for a seamless, custom fit. At Crank’s, we utilize Phoenix Liners, recognized for their thickness, durability, and long-lasting finish.

Pros:

• Permanent bond — won’t shift or trap water: Unlike drop-in options, spray-in liners create a strong bond that prevents movement or moisture issues, improving protection by approximately 40%.

  
  

• Resistant to UV rays and fading (especially with our UV coating upgrade): This protection helps to maintain the appearance of your truck bed, resisting fading for years.

  
  

• Looks clean and professional: Spray-in bedliners provide a sleek, custom look that enhances your truck’s overall style.

  
  

• Adds resale value to your truck: A well-protected truck bed can potentially boost your truck's resale value by 10% or more.

  
  

Cons:

• Higher upfront investment: Prices typically range from $500 to over $1,200 depending on the complexity of the installation.

  
  

• Can’t be removed once applied (though that’s usually a good thing!): While this permanence guarantees protection, it also means you cannot opt for a different liner later on.

  
  

Best for:

Truck owners looking to keep their vehicle long-term, haul heavy loads, or seeking top-tier protection.

Side-by-Side Comparison Table

Feature | Spray-In Bedliner | Drop-In Bedliner |

|-----------------------|-------------------|------------------|

| Durability ★★★★★ | ★★★☆☆

| Water Protection ★★★★★ | ★★☆☆☆

| Appearance Custom & seamless | Plastic & bulky

| Cost Higher upfront | Lower upfront

| Noise Level Quiet | Loud & rattles over time

Why Crank’s Recommends Spray-In Bedliners

Our experience shows that drop-in bedliners often trap moisture, which can lead to rust that ruins your truck bed. With our Phoenix Liners, we guarantee quality and durability to keep your truck bed protected for years.

Spray-in bedliners not only provide superior protection but also improve the overall look and resale value of your vehicle. Their seamless finish and custom fit make them the ideal choice for truck owners who want to maintain the integrity of their investment.

Get a Quote

Your Truck Bed Protection Decision

Choosing between spray-in and drop-in bedliners ultimately depends on your needs and preferences. If you're looking for a budget-friendly option and plan to trade your truck in soon, a drop-in bedliner might suit you. However, if you desire long-lasting protection and a professional appearance, the spray-in bedliner is your best bet.

At Crank’s Bedliners & Truck Accessories, we’re dedicated to helping you make the right choice for your truck. With our expertise and high-quality products, you can be confident that your truck bed will be well-protected.

No matter which option you select, investing in truck bed protection is essential. Don’t wait until it’s too late; protect your investment today!